as a kid, i attended camp broadstone, a summer camp associated with appalachian state university, that is now (sadly) closed. one of the desserts that the kitchen staff made at least once every session was sour cream apple pie. the first time i tried it, i was astonished with how good it was...so light and fluffy.
a few years ago, i decided to replicate a version of this pie. after researching the internet, i found two recipes that looked interesting: one for a topping and one for the filling. naturally, i smashed the two recipes together into a single brilliant combination. yes, i'm very modest about my success.
as desserts go, this is one with a longer than average prep time. truthfully, it probably takes upwards of 45 minutes or more to prepare. but i rather think that the time is worth it. i generally end up cutting the pie into eighths, so it lasts...well, considerably less than eight days.
ingredients:
(crumble topping)
- 1/2 cup brown sugar
- 1/3 cup flour
- 1/4 cup butter/margarine
- 1 teaspoon cinnamon
- pinch of salt
(filling)
- 1 1/3 cup sour cream
- 2/3 cup white sugar
- 1/4 teaspoon salt
- dash of cinnamon
- 2 teaspoons vanilla
- 2 eggs
- 3 tablespoons flour
- 5-6 cups sliced apples (i used granny smith)
- shelled pecans
preparation:
first, blend all the crumble topping ingredients together in a bowl, cover, and chill. ideally, this would be done the day before you make the pie so that it can firm up overnight in the refrigerator. however, in a pinch, just stick it in the freezer for a half-hour before you start the rest of the pie filling.
for the pie filling, peel, core, and thinly slice several apples. i've learned that a potato peeler is an excellent tool for peeling apples, and then it's just a matter of slicing them up. in order to get 5-6 cups, i used four medium-sized apples. i used granny smith because it's a good pie apple (holds up well during baking) and because there weren't any pink lady apples in the grocery store. sadness.
whisk the sour cream, sugar, salt, vanilla, eggs, and flour (and a dusting of cinnamon) until smooth. since i've noticed an improvement in my omelets when i incorporate some air into the mixture with the whisk, i tried to do the same with this pie filling. add a double handful of shelled pecans (i didn't try to measure them) and the apples, and stir until all the apples are well-coated.
spoon the filling into a pie crust (i'll admit that i cheated and used a pre-made refrigerated crust). i didn't try to arrange the apple slices, but i did at least try to ensure that they were in layers (not just haphazardly poured into the pan).
take the topping mixture and crumble it evenly onto the pie filling. it should be enough to fully cover the exposed apple mixture. bake at 350°F for 1 hour 10 minutes. testing doneness with a toothpick should find the apples tender and the toothpick coming out clean.
let pie cool before serving.
verdict:
it's been awhile since i've baked it, so i had forgotten how much i enjoy this pie. i love how sour cream gets all light and fluffy when baked (even if i don't like sour cream in general), but i probably could have cooked the pie about 10 minutes more to get the filling to set just a little more.
five cups of apples almost looks like it is insufficient in the pan, but i think it's actually just about perfect; the pie filling lifts up when baking, and if any more apples were added, i think that filling would start spilling over the edge (and onto the bottom of the oven). normally, i try to add a cookie sheet under the pan to catch drips, but i forgot to do that this time...so it's just as well i didn't have excessive filling.
aside from that, i didn't add enough pecans. in the future, i probably should add a few to the top of the apples (before adding the brown sugar crumble). i've added nuts to the very top before, but those end up getting blackened because there's no coating to prevent them from burning...i suspect that putting a layer of pecans under the brown sugar would allow the topping to coat the nuts and toast them (without burning).